SYNCTECH
Email delivery · · by the Synctech team

DMARC p=none, quarantine or reject: which should you set?

DMARC p=none, quarantine or reject: which should you set?

Most small businesses should start DMARC at p=none, read the reports for at least a week, then move to p=quarantine for a small share of mail, and only reach p=reject once every real sender passes. Google and Microsoft both advise this slow order. Jumping straight to reject can stop your own invoices and website emails from arriving.

What do the three policies do?

The policy is the p= part of your DMARC record. It tells the receiving mail server what to do with a message that claims to be from your domain but fails the check.

Policy What the receiver does with failing mail Risk to your own mail
p=none Delivers it as normal and only reports it None. This is the test stage
p=quarantine Accepts it but puts it in spam or junk Real mail that fails lands in the customer's spam folder
p=reject Refuses it, so it is never delivered Real mail that fails bounces back to you

Microsoft notes that the receiving system makes the final call, so two providers may handle the same failing message a little differently.

Which one should a small business use?

Start with none. Google says to set up SPF and DKIM at least 48 hours before you add DMARC, then run p=none for about a week, because a week of daily reports usually shows every system that sends mail as you.

Move to quarantine once the reports show your real senders passing. You do not have to switch all mail at once. The pct= tag sets the share of failing mail the policy applies to. Google suggests a small office could start at 10 percent, and Microsoft suggests raising it in several steps until it covers all failing mail.

Choose reject when quarantine at 100 percent has run for a while with no complaints. It gives the strongest protection against people faking your address, which is the trick behind many fake invoice emails. Microsoft names reject as the end goal for every domain you own.

How do I read the DMARC reports?

The rua=mailto: address in your record receives aggregate reports, usually once a day from each mail provider that received your mail. Each one is an attached file listing which servers sent mail as your domain and whether SPF and DKIM passed.

The raw files are hard to read by eye. A free DMARC report reader can turn them into a simple list. Look for two things:

  • A server you recognise that fails. That is a real sender to fix before you go further, such as a website form, an online shop, a newsletter tool or an accounting system.
  • A server you do not recognise that fails. That is often someone faking your domain, and it is exactly what quarantine and reject will block.

Use a separate mailbox such as dmarc@yourdomain.com.my for reports, so they do not flood a staff inbox.

Gmail or Outlook still bounces my mail. What now?

A DMARC record alone does not make mail pass. Gmail asks that the domain in your From address match the domain checked by SPF or DKIM. This is called alignment. Common causes of a bounce after DMARC goes in:

  1. A system sends as your domain but is not in your SPF record and does not sign with your DKIM key.
  2. DKIM is switched on at your provider but the key was never published in DNS, so only SPF is left to pass.
  3. The DMARC policy moved to reject before the reports were clean.

If bounces start after a change, go back one step (reject to quarantine, or quarantine to none), fix the sender in the reports, then move forward again. Google also requires anyone sending more than 5,000 messages a day to Gmail to have DMARC, even if only at p=none.

What to do

  1. Check that SPF and DKIM pass with one test email. Our guide on how to check SPF, DKIM and DMARC records shows how.
  2. Add v=DMARC1; p=none; rua=mailto:dmarc@yourdomain.com.my at _dmarc.yourdomain.com.my.
  3. Read the reports for at least one week and fix every real sender that fails.
  4. Change the policy to quarantine with pct set to 10, then raise the pct value step by step until it covers all mail.
  5. When quarantine at 100 percent is quiet, decide with your IT person whether to move to p=reject.
  6. Keep reading the reports every month. A new tool that sends mail as you will show up there first.

How SyncTech can help

If the reports are hard to read or your mail keeps bouncing, our email troubleshooting team can review your SPF, DKIM and DMARC setup and tell you which policy is safe for your domain now.

Source and credit

We are sharing information from Google and Microsoft. This guide is written by Synctech in our own words.

Related announcements

Questions? Open a ticket or WhatsApp +6016-7618518.